Peer Assessment of Medical Lecturing: A Faculty Development Instrument

Publication ID Published Version
9359 March 11, 2013 1


Peer observation of teaching has become an important element in the assessment of faculty members’ instructional skills and competence. Identifying and assessing teaching accurately involves use of reliable and validated instruments, standardized observation procedures, and peer observer training. Without training, observers may provide biased feedback that lacks sufficient detail or specific suggestions needed for teaching improvement.

In 2007, we took part in the development, research, and publication of a Peer Assessment of Medical Lecturing Instrument. The instrument consists of 11 criteria of effective lecturing and an overall lecture quality measure. We then formed an expert panel to determine a full complement of behavioral descriptors and performance standards for each of the instrument’s criteria.

Over two years, we observed and rated lectures and catalogued performance behaviors associated with each of the instrument’s criteria. This process led to the development of a Rater Training Facilitator’s Guide to accompany the Peer Assessment of Medical Lecturing Instrument. Together, the guide and instrument may be used for peer rater training as it provides faculty with detailed behavioral descriptors and guidance on conducting peer assessment of medical lecturing or large group discussions.


Newman L, Brodsky D, Roberts D, Atkins K, Schwartzstein R. Peer Assessment of Medical Lecturing: A Faculty Development Instrument. MedEdPORTAL Publications; 2013. Available from:

Educational Objectives

  1. To encourage peer observation of teaching among faculty members resulting in specific, behavioral feedback and valuable discussions on best teaching practices.
  2. To provide faculty observers with detailed guidance on how to conduct peer observation using a standardized, reliable approach.
  3. To provide a peer assessment of teaching instrument along with behavioral descriptors and rating standards derived by a panel of medical education experts to be used for peer observer training, formative and/or summative lecture assessment, or as a reference tool.


  • Peer Observation, Peer Review, Peer Rater Training, Lecturing, Lectures, Large Group Discussion, Peer Evaluations


  • Dental


  • Interpersonal & Communication Skills
  • Practice-based Learning & Improvement
    • Incorporate feedback
  • Professionalism

Professional Interest

  • Assessment
  • Communication Skills
  • Evaluation of Clinical Performance
  • Instructional Materials/Methods
  • Teaching Skills
  • weTeach

Instructional Methods

  • Assessment
  • Independent Learning

Assessment Methods

  • Peer Assessment

Academic Focus

  • Clinical Sciences
    • Clinical Skills/Doctoring

Intended Audience

  • Professional & Faculty Development
  • Professional School
    • Dental Student
    • Medical Student
  • Professional School Post-Graduate Training
    • Fellow
    • Resident


  • Evaluation Tool

Join the Conversation

Share your thoughts with other users. Please sign in to comment on this material.

Material Access

Please sign in to access this material.

Please register for an AAMC account if you do not have one.


Browse Publications

Subscribe to Our Monthly Newsletter

Receive featured content & announcements!

  • Register
  • My MedEdPORTAL
  • Contact Us
  • My MedEdPORTAL

ISSN 2374-8265