UCSF LEaP (Learning from your Experiences as a Professional): Guidelines for Critical Reflection

Publication ID Published Volume
9073 January 9, 2012 8

Abstract

Introduction: Since the late 1990s, accrediting bodies and oversight organizations have recognized reflection as an essential skill for health professionals and an important tool for competency-based assessment. As a result, educators and clinicians across the medical education spectrum are looking for guidance in the teaching and development of reflective ability. Based on a literature review and survey, we developed a consensus definition of reflection and created the Learning From Your Experiences as a Professional (LEaP) Guidelines, a brief, stand-alone guide which would be instructive to both medical students and faculty. Methods: The guidelines resource is contained in a three-page document. The first page includes student instructions on the effective use of reflection. Page two consists of a reflective exercise modeled on the clinical SOAP (Chief Complaint/Identification, Subjective, Objective, Assessment, and Plan) note. Page three concludes with a review of frequently asked questions. The sresource takes approximately 1 hour to administer. Results: We conducted a randomized trial of the LEaP guidelines in third year medical students at the University of California, San Francisco. We assigned half our sample of 167 students to receive the LEaP guidelines and half to receive only a definition of critical reflection in medical education. We found that the LEaP guidelines improved performance. Mean reflection scores were 3.81 (sd = 1.9) using LEaP guidelines and 2.22 (sd = .89) without the guidelines (p < .001). Discussion: In reflective learning, as in clinical practice, it appears that guidelines improve performance. Although to date more work has been done on assessing reflection skills in learners, it stands to reason that teaching the characteristics of more effective reflection and helping learners acquire the skills to reflect well should occur in conjunction with evaluations of their ability to do so. Questions remain about the dose and timing of instruction and guideline guided exercises needed to develop reliable reflective skill.

Citation

Aronson L, Kruidering M, Niehaus B, O'Sullivan P. UCSF LEaP (learning from your experiences as a professional): guidelines for critical reflection. MedEdPORTAL Publications. 2012;8:9073. http://doi.org/10.15766/mep_2374-8265.9073

Educational Objectives

By the end of this session, learners will be able to:

  1. Distinguish critical reflection from reflection.
  2. Identify the role of critical reflection in professional development.
  3. List the components of a critical reflection.
  4. Use the Subjective, Objective, Assessment, and Plan note template provided in the Learning From Your Experiences as a Professional Guidelines to produce a critical reflection.

Keywords

  • Reflection, Diagnostic Self-Evaluation, Professional Competence

References

  1. Aronson L, Niehaus B, DeVries C, Siegel J, O’Sullivan P. Do Writing and Storytelling Skill Influence Assessment of Reflective Ability in Medical Students’ Written Reflections? Academic Medicine 2010; 85(10): S29-S32. http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181ed3aa7
  2. Aronson L, Niehaus B, Lindow J, Robertson P, O’Sullivan P. Development and Pilot Testing of a Reflective Learning Guide for Medical Education. Med Teach. 2011;33(10):e515-21. http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2011.599894
  3. Aronson L, Niehaus B, Hill-Sakurai L, Lai C, O’Sullivan P. A Randomized Trial of Reflective Learning Guidelines and Feedback among Third Year Medical Students. (submitted)
  4. Aronson L, Niehaus B, Hill-Sakurai L, Lai C, O’Sullivan P. A Randomized Trial of Reflective Learning Guidelines and Feedback Among Third Year Medical Students. Western Group on Educational Affairs Annual Meetings and UCSF Education Day, April 2011.
  5. Aronson L, Robertson P, Lindow J, O’Sullivan P. Guidelines for Reflective Writing Produce Higher Quality Reflections. American Association of Medical Colleges, National Meeting, November 2009.
  6. Aronson L, Topp K, Kruidering M. Teaching Reflection to First Year Medical Students: Applications to an Early Leadership Experience. Western Group on Educational Affairs Annual Meeting and UCSF Education Day, April 2010.ons to an Early Leadership Experience. Western Group on Educational Affairs Annual Meeting and UCSF Education Day, April 2010.

Material Access

Please sign in to access this material.

Please register for an AAMC account if you do not have one.

Register

Associated Content

Series (2)

  • Contact Us

Subscribe to Our Quarterly Newsletter

Receive featured content & announcements!

ISSN 2374-8265